Selvala, Heart of the Wilds: A Powerful Card with Unlimited Potential

The recent removal of Banned as Commander (BAC) has sparked controversy among Magic players, with many wondering why this unique mechanic was taken away. For those who may not be familiar, BAC allowed cards like Selvala, Heart of the Wilds 99 to thrive in Commander format. But what makes these cards so powerful, and is their removal a step backwards for the game?

At its core, the power of Lurrus and similar companion cards lies in their ability to recur cards from the graveyard every turn. This effect may seem broken at first glance, but it's essential to understand that it's not the card itself that's overpowered – it's the guaranteed access to a zone separate from your deck. This separation allows for strategic plays and combos that wouldn't be possible otherwise.

Take Lurrus of the Dream-Den as an example. As a banned commander, its ability to recur cards from the graveyard is a major factor in its success. But with Selvala, Heart of the Wilds 99, we have a card that can do something similar – albeit in a slightly different way. By allowing us to recur our own creatures and spells, Selvala enables us to build powerful combos and strategies that would be difficult or impossible without it.

So why did the RC remove BAC? The reasons behind this decision are complex, but ultimately boil down to a desire for simplicity and streamlining. The RC felt that having two banlists – one for Commander and another for Banned as Commander – was unnecessary information overhead and made the game more complicated than it needed to be.

However, some players see this removal as a lack of faith in their ability to understand and navigate multiple banlists. After all, why should Commander players be treated any differently than other formats? The answer lies in the nuances of each format and the specific needs of its players. In Commander, the unique interactions between cards and the emphasis on individual creativity make BAC an essential part of the game.

Ultimately, the removal of BAC may have simplified things for new players, but it has also removed a layer of depth and complexity from the game. As Magic players, we should be careful not to lose sight of what makes our format special – and that includes cards like Selvala, Heart of the Wilds 99.

Selvala heart of the wilds 99